Otero County Sheriff's Office, New Mexico
End of Watch Tuesday, February 13, 1923
Add to My HeroesWilliam L. Rutherford
Sheriff William Rutherford was shot and killed while investigating two men who matched the description of prisoners who had just escaped from a neighboring county.
He approached the car and asked the men if he could search it. As the men tried to pull away the sheriff jumped on the running board. One of the men inside then shot him with a 30-30 rifle that had been stolen from the deputies in the previous escape.
The men were eventually apprehended and sentenced to death but later had their sentenced commuted and then pardoned by the Governor.
Sheriff Rutherford had only served with the Otero County Sheriff's Department for six weeks.
Bio
- Age 40
- Tour 1 month, 2 weeks
- Badge Not available
Incident Details
- Cause Gunfire
- Weapon Rifle; .30-.30
- Offender Pardoned
Most Recent Reflection
View all 7 ReflectionsSheriff Rutherford,
On today, the 100th anniversary of your death I would just like to say thank you for your service and sacrifice for the citizens of Otero County.
R.I.P.
USBP
Anonymous
United States Border Patrol
February 13, 2023
Recent LODD Deaths

Detective Joseph Azcona
Newark Police Division, NJ
EOW: March 7, 2025

Police Officer Felicia Dee Reilly
Saint Paul Police Department, MN
EOW: March 1, 2025

Deputy Sergeant Martin Shields, Jr.
Hinds County Sheriff's Office, MS
EOW: February 23, 2025

Police Officer Christopher M. L. Reese
Virginia Beach Police Department, VA
EOW: February 22, 2025

Police Officer Cameron Robert Girvin
Virginia Beach Police Department, VA
EOW: February 22, 2025

Patrolman Andrew William Duarte
West York Borough Police Department, PA
EOW: February 22, 2025

Trooper Kyle McAcy
Nebraska State Patrol, NE
EOW: February 17, 2025

Police Officer Jeremy R. Labonte
Roswell Police Department, GA
EOW: February 7, 2025

Officer Jason Roscow
North Las Vegas Police Department, NV
EOW: February 4, 2025